QUICK SUMMARY · KEY TAKEAWAYS
- The Grilled Chicken Sandwich ($7.49) includes melted American cheese, crisp lettuce, ripe tomato, onion, and signature Pretty Patty sauce.
- The Crispy Chicken Sandwich ($7.99) swaps cheese and onion for tangy pickles, creamy mayo, plus Pretty Patty sauce to spotlight its shatter-crisp breading.
- Both sandwiches qualify for the +$3.99 Make It a Combo upgrade (Fries or Tots + Fountain Drink), keeping your complete lunch right around $11–$12.
- Custom add-ons like beef bacon (+$2.99), jalapeños (+$0.99), or extra cheese (+$0.99) let you tailor either sandwich in seconds.
Why Grilled Chicken Sandwich ($7.49) vs. Crispy Chicken Sandwich ($7.99) Stands Out in Indianapolis
Standing at the counter craving chicken instead of beef, caught between juicy grilled flavor and golden hand-breaded crunch? You are definitely not alone—hungry diners across Castleton, Lawrence, and northeast Indy ask our crew about this every single day at Pretty Patty on N Shadeland Ave.
We put our $7.49 Grilled Chicken Sandwich and $7.99 Crispy Chicken Sandwich head-to-head so you pick the exact build your lunch break needs. Instead of vague hype, let us walk through exact ingredients, real menu prices ($7.49 and $7.99), flavor pairings, and insider ordering strategies so your very next meal hits 10 out of 10.
At Pretty Patty, every single ticket is cooked fresh to order starting at 10:30 AM daily. Whether you are grabbing a quick solo lunch between meetings, feeding kids after practice, or planning a weekend feast via our Chicken sandwich menu, knowing how each layer works on the plate helps you order like a day-one regular.
Even better, you never have to overpay for scratch-made comfort food in Indy. By combining fresh flat-top searing, house-breaded crunch, and smart value upgrades across our full Indianapolis menu, you get bold flavor that leaves lukewarm drive-thru bags in the rearview mirror.
Topping Architecture: Why Each Sandwich Uses Its Own Build
Notice that we do not lazily slap the exact same toppings onto both chicken sandwiches. Because seasoned grilled chicken breast has a clean, savory sear, pairing it with melted American cheese, fresh sliced onion, ripe tomato, crisp lettuce, and Pretty Patty sauce ($7.49) gives every bite melty richness and garden crunch.
Hand-breaded crispy chicken ($7.99), on the other hand, thrives on acidity and creaminess against hot fried crust. Layering crinkle pickles, smooth mayo, signature Pretty Patty sauce, lettuce, and tomato keeps the breading crisp while delivering that unmistakable southern chicken-sandwich snap.
Whichever camp you join today, adding fries or tots and a drink for +$3.99 keeps your entire fresh-cooked Shadeland lunch fast, filling, and affordable.
If you want to see how our kitchen applies that exact same made-to-order discipline across other stations, check out our hand-breaded chicken tenders and meals guide right after finishing this guide.
Step-by-Step: How to Customize Your Ultimate Order
One of the biggest secrets on the Pretty Patty menu is how flexible our Kids & Extras upgrade bar is. You do not have to stick strictly to the default board build when an extra dollar or two unlocks your personal dream stack.
Follow this simple four-step playbook the next time you walk up to our royal-blue counter at 7554 N Shadeland Ave:
- Step 1 — Lock In Your Anchor Item: Start with your main craving from Chicken sandwich menu or compare it against signature benchmarks like our Homepage Favorites.
- Step 2 — Dial Up Texture or Heat: Add sliced jalapeños (+$0.99) for bright pepper snap, sweet grilled onions (+$0.99) for deep caramelization, extra cheese (+$0.99), a freshly cooked fried egg (+$1.49), an extra smashed beef patty (+$2.29), or smoky beef bacon (+$2.99).
- Step 3 — Trigger the +$3.99 Combo Multiplier: Whenever you order an eligible burger or chicken sandwich, adding hot golden Fries or Crispy Tots plus a fountain drink for just +$3.99 delivers the strongest dollar-for-dollar value in northeast Indy.
- Step 4 — Add a Shareable Table Centerpiece: Splitting 6 Piece Wings ($8.99), Onion Rings ($3.49), or Cheese Fries ($4.99) gives everyone at the booth extra variety without doubling the tab.
Best Drink, Shake, and Side Pairings to Complete the Meal
Great fast-casual meals come down to contrast: hot meets cold, crispy meets creamy, and spicy meets sweet. That is why pairing Grilled Chicken Sandwich ($7.49) vs. Crispy Chicken Sandwich ($7.99) with the right drink or side elevates every single bite from start to finish.
If you lean toward rich, ice-cold sweetness, our 16 oz Pretty Shakes ($5.99) come spun thick in eight crowd-favorite flavors—Vanilla, Strawberry, Chocolate, Oreo, Banana Split, Caramel, Fruity Pebbles, and Cinnamon Toast Crunch. You can dive deeper into our favorite combinations in our fresh Grilled and Crispy Chicken Salads guide.
Prefer a crisp, non-dairy boost for the second half of your workday? Grab a 16 oz Charge Up Energy ($5.89) in Peach Rush, Blue Raspberry, Cherry Charge, Strawberry Surge, or Watermelon Wave (with zero-sugar options ready), or keep it classic with Pepsi fountain favorites, lemonade, sweet tea, and fruit punch.
For groups dining together, mixing one sweet 16 oz shake with one refreshing fountain drink or Charge Up Energy gives the table the best of both worlds—creamy dessert indulgence alongside crisp, palate-cleansing sips between savory bites.
Local Indianapolis Tips: Dine-In, Takeout, and Group Orders
Situated right at 7554 N Shadeland Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46250, Pretty Patty sits in an easy sweet spot for northeast Indy drivers coming off I-465, 75th Street, Castleton Square, Lawrence, or Geist. Parking is right outside the front doors, so quick lunch runs never burn half your break hunting for a garage spot.
Dine-in guests get the full sizzle-and-aroma experience right as trays leave the pass, complete with bold royal-blue booths and upbeat energy. Taking food home instead? Our crew packs hot items immediately as they finish cooking so buns stay toasted, fries stay crisp, and cold shakes stay thick.
And if one taste convinces you to bring these flavors to your next Friday office meeting, birthday party, or football watch party, jump straight to our Pretty Patty catering details to plan a customized spread for your whole crew.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the Grilled Chicken Sandwich come with cheese?
Yes! The $7.49 Grilled Chicken Sandwich comes standard with melted American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and Pretty Patty sauce.
What toppings come on the Crispy Chicken Sandwich?
The $7.99 Crispy Chicken Sandwich features hand-breaded crispy chicken, fresh lettuce, tomato, pickles, mayo, and signature Pretty Patty sauce on a toasted bun.
Can I make either chicken sandwich spicy?
Easily—add sliced jalapeños (+$0.99) to either sandwich, or pair your sandwich with Hot Chicken Fries ($10.99) or Mango Habanero wings.
Do both chicken sandwiches qualify for the $3.99 combo?
Yes, both the Grilled Chicken Sandwich and Crispy Chicken Sandwich can be upgraded with hot Fries or Crispy Tots and a drink for +$3.99.
Final Takeaway: Order Fresh on N Shadeland Ave
Bottom line: when you want real, scratch-cooked flavor in Indianapolis without waiting forty minutes at a sit-down chain, Grilled Chicken Sandwich ($7.49) vs. Crispy Chicken Sandwich ($7.99) at Pretty Patty delivers every single time. From crispy-edge flat-top craft and hand-breaded crunch to thick 16 oz shakes and wallet-smart $3.99 combos, every detail on N Shadeland Ave is built around fresh satisfaction.
Ready to map out your next order? Browse every category right now on our interactive Pretty Patty menu, check today's hours under Visit Pretty Patty, or keep exploring more local food guides across the Pretty Patty Blog.




